The True Cost of an Amazon Shop

Are We Sacrificing Competition, Communities and Sustainability for Convenience?

Amazon has transformed the way we shop. It offers convenience, choice and rapid delivery on a scale previously unimaginable. Yet behind the one-click checkout lies a wider debate about competition, the future of Britain’s high streets, environmental sustainability, labour standards and the hidden costs of modern consumer culture.


Has Amazon Become Too Powerful?

For millions of people, Amazon has become the default destination for online shopping. Whether buying books, electronics, clothing or household essentials, consumers can find almost anything with a few clicks and have it delivered within days, sometimes hours.

Yet beneath this convenience lies a difficult question: has Amazon become so large that it is making it harder for other businesses to compete fairly?

As Britain’s high streets continue to struggle, critics argue that Amazon’s dominance risks creating a retail landscape where independent traders disappear, local economies weaken and consumers become increasingly dependent upon a handful of global corporations.


The Myth of Always Being Cheapest

One of Amazon’s greatest strengths is its reputation for low prices. Many shoppers automatically assume Amazon offers the best deal available.

However, that assumption is not always correct.

Independent retailers, local businesses and specialist online stores can often match or undercut Amazon on many products. What Amazon has mastered is not simply price but convenience, visibility and habit.

Consumers increasingly begin their search on Amazon rather than comparing alternatives elsewhere. This creates a powerful cycle whereby more customers attract more sellers, attracting yet more customers and making it increasingly difficult for smaller competitors to gain visibility.

The risk is that competition becomes concentrated within Amazon’s ecosystem rather than existing between genuinely independent rivals.


Why Choice Matters

A healthy economy depends upon competition.

When consumers can choose between multiple retailers, businesses are forced to improve quality, reduce prices, innovate and provide better service. Competition encourages entrepreneurship and creates opportunities for new market entrants.

However, if one platform becomes overwhelmingly dominant, competition becomes weaker over time.

The danger is not just higher prices in the future. It is the gradual loss of genuine alternatives.

Today’s convenience may eventually become tomorrow’s dependence.


The Decline of the High Street

The decline of Britain’s high streets cannot be blamed solely on Amazon. Rising business rates, online shopping, changing consumer behaviour, energy costs and economic pressures have all played significant roles.

Nevertheless, online retail has fundamentally reshaped how people shop.

According to the Office for National Statistics, retail employment on central British high streets fell by 19% between 2015 and 2024 as shopping activity increasingly shifted online.

The consequences are visible across Britain. Empty units, reduced footfall and the loss of familiar retailers such as Debenhams and Wilko have become common features of many towns and city centres.

A thriving high street provides more than shopping opportunities. It supports local employment, creates social spaces, nurtures entrepreneurship and helps money circulate within local communities.

When independent shops disappear, communities often lose far more than places to buy products.


The Competition Question

Amazon’s influence has drawn scrutiny from regulators.

The UK’s Competition and Markets Authority investigated concerns that Amazon’s marketplace practices could disadvantage third-party sellers and distort competition. The investigation resulted in legally binding commitments relating to seller data and the operation of Amazon’s influential Buy Box system.

The question remains whether businesses selling through Amazon are truly competing with Amazon or are increasingly dependent upon a platform whose rules it controls.


Looking Beyond the Checkout

The most important criticism of Amazon may extend beyond economics altogether.

When we purchase a cheap t-shirt, a toy, a kitchen gadget or a television, we rarely consider the full journey behind the product.

Raw materials may be extracted in one country, manufactured in another, assembled elsewhere, transported across oceans and finally delivered to a British doorstep.

The environmental consequences are substantial.

Britain’s official consumption-based carbon footprint shows that imported emissions now account for more than half of the UK’s total carbon footprint. While domestic emissions have fallen considerably, a significant environmental impact has effectively been exported overseas.

The convenience of online shopping can make these global impacts largely invisible to consumers.


Fast Consumption, Fast Consequences

The issue becomes particularly visible in fast fashion.

The United Nations Environment Programme estimates that the textile industry generates between 2% and 8% of global greenhouse gas emissions while consuming vast quantities of water and creating significant pollution.

Consumers are purchasing more clothing than ever before while wearing it for less time. Vast amounts of textile waste end up in landfill each year.

Amazon did not create this culture, but platforms like Amazon have undoubtedly made the purchase of inexpensive, disposable products easier and faster than ever before.

Convenience can sometimes encourage consumption without encouraging reflection.


The Human Cost of Global Supply Chains

Global trade has created opportunities for millions of people around the world and contributed significantly to economic development in many countries.

Yet concerns remain regarding working conditions throughout complex international supply chains.

The International Labour Organization continues to identify challenges relating to wages, labour rights, discrimination and working conditions within parts of the global garment and manufacturing sectors.

Similarly, the United Nations Global Compact has highlighted the importance of human rights due diligence within supply chains due to the continuing risk that exploitation can remain hidden within complex production networks.

No responsible observer should assume every imported product is unethical.

However, neither should consumers assume that remarkably low prices come without cost.

Sometimes the true cost is borne elsewhere through lower wages, weaker environmental protections or less robust labour standards.


A Personal Confession: Why I Still Use Amazon

At this point, I should probably make a confession.

Despite many of the concerns raised in this article, I have bought items from Amazon myself, including Christmas presents for family and friends.

The reason is simple.

I do not particularly enjoy spending hours travelling between busy shops searching for products that may not even be available. Many of us have experienced the frustration of visiting several stores and returning home empty-handed.

Amazon solves that problem remarkably well.

The sheer variety available through a single website is extraordinary. Delivery times are often impressive, and prices can sometimes be highly competitive.

Some people I know refuse to purchase from Amazon on principle, and I completely respect that position.

Personally, I try to take a balanced approach.

For food shopping, I often prefer retailers such as the Co-op because of their commitment to local suppliers and local produce. When purchasing larger items such as laptops or desktop computers, I frequently favour local suppliers because they provide expertise, after-sales support and somewhere to turn if things go wrong.

Supporting local businesses helps local economies, creates local jobs and keeps money circulating within communities.

Yet I would be dishonest if I claimed I could completely abandon Amazon.

There are times when the company’s variety, convenience, speed of delivery and competitive pricing make it the most practical choice available.

Like many consumers, I suspect I live somewhere between principle and practicality.


The challenge is not necessarily to stop using Amazon altogether, but to become more conscious about when, why and how we use it.


Conclusion

My own relationship with Amazon reflects what is perhaps a wider contradiction within modern consumer society.

Like many people, I value convenience, efficiency and choice. Yet I also value thriving high streets, local businesses, sustainable production and fair treatment of workers.

That tension sits at the heart of the Amazon debate.

The question is not whether Amazon is entirely good or entirely bad. The reality is far more complicated.

Amazon is not solely responsible for declining high streets, environmental damage or labour concerns within global supply chains. But it has become one of the most visible symbols of a wider economic system built around convenience, scale and consumption.

The real issue therefore extends beyond Amazon itself.

It is about whether modern consumer culture has disconnected us from the true cost of what we buy.

The cheapest product is not always the cheapest for society.

The fastest delivery is not always the most sustainable.

The most convenient choice is not always the one that strengthens communities or preserves competition.

A healthy economy requires more than efficiency. It requires diversity, resilience, accountability, sustainability and genuine choice.

Consumers cannot solve these issues alone. Governments must ensure fair competition. Businesses must operate responsibly. Supply chains should meet higher environmental and human rights standards.

And consumers, where possible, can make informed decisions about where their money goes.

Perhaps the answer is neither to embrace Amazon uncritically nor reject it entirely.

Instead, it is to recognise that every purchase carries consequences.

The challenge for all of us is not simply to become better shoppers, but better citizens, asking not only what something costs today, but what it may cost society tomorrow.


References

  1. Competition and Markets Authority. Investigation into Amazon’s Marketplace.
  2. Competition and Markets Authority. Amazon Competition Investigation.
  3. Office for National Statistics. High Streets and Retail Areas in Great Britain.
  4. Office for National Statistics. Retail Sales, Great Britain.
  5. DEFRA. Carbon Footprint for the UK and England.
  6. Office for National Statistics. Measuring UK Greenhouse Gas Emissions.
  7. United Nations Environment Programme. Minimizing Fashion’s Environmental Footprint.
  8. United Nations Environment Programme. The Environmental Costs of Fast Fashion.
  9. International Labour Organization. Advancing Decent Work in Supply Chains.
  10. United Nations Global Compact. Human Rights in Supply Chains.
  11. UK Parliament Committee Evidence. High Streets and Town Centres in 2030.
  12. Centre for Cities. Checking Out: The Varying Performance of High Streets Across the Country.

Author: Huw Edwards

Published by: HuwSpace.com

The Three Wise Monkeys and China: Prosperity Without Questions?

China’s economic rise is one of the most remarkable stories of the modern age. In little more than a generation, hundreds of millions have been lifted from poverty, world-class infrastructure has emerged from farmland, and Chinese industry has become central to the global economy.

Yet alongside this achievement sits a difficult question: has much of the world adopted the attitude of the Three Wise Monkeys when dealing with China?

The ancient image is familiar. One monkey covers its eyes, another its ears, and a third its mouth.

See no evil.

Hear no evil.

Speak no evil.

In the context of China, the symbolism is striking.

See No Evil

The first monkey closes its eyes.

Around the world, governments, businesses and consumers have enthusiastically embraced Chinese-made goods, Chinese investment and access to Chinese markets. The benefits are obvious. Products are often cheaper. Supply chains are efficient. Growth opportunities can be enormous.

But closing our eyes to uncomfortable realities carries risks.

Questions continue to be raised internationally regarding restrictions on political freedoms, surveillance technologies, treatment of minority groups, pressures on cultural identities, and environmental consequences associated with rapid industrialisation.

For many investors and consumers, however, these issues remain secondary to economic opportunity. The world’s appetite for affordable goods can sometimes create a willingness not to look too closely at how those goods are produced or the political conditions in which production occurs.

Hear No Evil

The second monkey covers its ears.

Critics often argue that dissenting voices about China struggle to be heard. Journalists, academics, activists, campaigners and international organisations may raise concerns about freedom of expression, human rights, Hong Kong, Tibet or other sensitive topics.

Yet those warnings frequently compete with a louder narrative centred on growth, trade and investment.

Many multinational corporations are cautious about criticising Beijing for fear of losing access to one of the world’s largest markets. Politicians may hesitate to challenge China too forcefully if doing so threatens jobs or economic relationships.

The result can be a tendency to hear economic success more clearly than political criticism.

Speak No Evil

The third monkey covers its mouth.

Perhaps the most interesting monkey is the last one.

Across the world there can be reluctance to openly criticise China. Businesses fear losing contracts. Universities fear losing funding. Governments fear diplomatic or economic retaliation. Consumers simply want affordable products.

Silence becomes a practical choice.

Yet history suggests that silence rarely removes problems. It merely postpones difficult conversations until they become impossible to avoid.

A mature relationship between nations should allow admiration and criticism to coexist. It should be possible to recognise China’s extraordinary achievements while also discussing legitimate concerns about freedom, accountability and environmental sustainability.

Looking in the Mirror

The Three Wise Monkeys metaphor ultimately tells us as much about ourselves as it does about China.

The real question is not whether China sees, hears or speaks evil.

The real question is whether the rest of the world does.

When a low-cost product arrives at our door the next day, when pension funds benefit from Chinese growth, when businesses profit from access to Chinese markets, it becomes easier to overlook the uncomfortable questions.

Economic success can be dazzling. Like the monkeys, we may sometimes choose not to see, not to hear and not to speak.

The challenge for the twenty-first century is to engage with China honestly, neither demonising nor romanticising the country. China is too important to be viewed through simplistic slogans. Its achievements deserve recognition. Its shortcomings deserve scrutiny.

If the world learns anything from the Three Wise Monkeys, it is that prosperity should never come at the expense of curiosity, truth and open discussion.

A stronger global future depends not on seeing less, hearing less and saying less, but on having the courage to do the opposite.

The Dark Side of the Deal: When Great Powers Decide the Fate of the World

From Yalta to the Present Day

History is often shaped not only by wars and revolutions but by private conversations between powerful leaders. In February 1945, Winston Churchill, Franklin D. Roosevelt, and Joseph Stalin met at Yalta to discuss the post-war world. Their decisions helped shape Europe for decades, but they also left millions of people living behind borders and political systems they had little say in choosing.

To many in Eastern Europe, Yalta became synonymous with a troubling reality: the fate of entire nations being negotiated by a handful of powerful men around a table.

Today, some commentators draw parallels between Yalta and the prospect of major negotiations involving Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping. The comparison is not perfect. The world of 2026 is vastly different from that of 1945. Yet the debate raises an important question:

What happens when the world’s most powerful leaders believe they can strike grand bargains over the heads of everyone else?

The Temptation of Great-Power Politics

Throughout history, powerful states have often divided the world into spheres of influence. Empires did it. Colonial powers did it. The great powers of the nineteenth century did it repeatedly.

The attraction is obvious. If powerful countries recognise each other’s interests, they may reduce the likelihood of direct conflict between themselves.

The cost, however, is frequently borne by smaller nations.

The concern expressed by many analysts is not that Trump, Putin and Xi would literally redraw maps in the way leaders once attempted. Rather, the worry is that a return to sphere-of-influence thinking could weaken the principle that sovereign nations should determine their own futures.

When major powers negotiate primarily with one another, smaller countries can become objects of policy rather than participants in it.

Ukraine: The Fear of Being Traded Away

Nowhere is this concern clearer than in Ukraine.

Since Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022, Ukrainians have repeatedly argued that any settlement must ultimately be decided by Ukraine itself, not imposed by outside powers.

Critics of great-power bargaining fear a situation in which larger states prioritise stability and expediency over justice and self-determination. History shows that peace agreements reached without the consent of those most affected often contain the seeds of future conflict.

The lesson of the twentieth century is that durable peace rarely survives if people believe their future has been negotiated without their voice.

Taiwan and the Indo-Pacific

A similar concern exists in Asia.

Taiwan, South Korea, Japan and many Southeast Asian nations closely watch the relationship between Washington, Beijing and Moscow.

For these countries, the issue is not simply military power. It is trust.

If security commitments become bargaining chips in wider geopolitical negotiations, allies may begin to doubt the reliability of international partnerships. Such uncertainty can encourage arms races, regional tensions and strategic instability.

The consequences extend far beyond any single summit or diplomatic meeting.

The Authoritarian Advantage

There is another concern that deserves attention.

Putin and Xi govern systems in which power is highly centralised. Political opposition is heavily constrained, and criticism of leadership carries significant risks.

Democratic societies are not perfect. They can be slow, messy and frustrating. Yet they contain mechanisms for criticism, correction and accountability.

The risk arises when democratic leaders begin to adopt an increasingly transactional view of international politics, treating complex human societies primarily as pieces on a geopolitical chessboard.

History demonstrates that when human rights, democratic legitimacy and individual liberty are subordinated to power politics, ordinary people are often the first to suffer.

Lessons from the Twentieth Century

The Yalta leaders faced extraordinary circumstances. They were attempting to conclude the deadliest war in human history.

Yet the aftermath revealed an uncomfortable truth.

To some, Yalta represented pragmatic statecraft. To others, it symbolised the abandonment of entire nations to decades of authoritarian rule.

Both interpretations contain elements of truth.

The lesson is not that diplomacy is wrong. Diplomacy is essential.

The lesson is that diplomacy should not take place at the expense of democratic consent, national sovereignty and human freedom.

When decisions affecting millions are made by a small group of leaders behind closed doors, the danger is not merely strategic error. The danger is that human beings become secondary considerations.

Why a Modern Yalta May Not Be Possible

There are important reasons why the world today differs from 1945.

Ukraine is not post-war Poland. Taiwan is not post-war Czechoslovakia. Nations across Europe and Asia possess strong identities, functioning governments and significant military capabilities.

Modern communications also make secret geopolitical bargains far harder to sustain.

In today’s interconnected world, populations are better informed, more politically engaged and less willing to accept decisions imposed from above.

This does not eliminate the risk of great-power deals, but it does limit the ability of any three leaders to determine the future alone.

The Real Danger

The true danger is not that Trump, Putin and Xi recreate Yalta exactly.

The real danger is the mindset that often accompanies concentrated power: the belief that history is made by a few strong leaders while everyone else simply lives with the consequences.

History suggests otherwise.

The greatest advances in freedom, democracy and human rights have rarely come from secret bargains between powerful men. They have come from ordinary people demanding a voice in their own future.

The world does not need a new Yalta.

It needs institutions, democracies and international agreements that place the interests of humanity above the ambitions of individuals.

Because whenever power becomes concentrated in too few hands, the question is never simply what leaders gain from the deal.

The question is who pays the price.

Trump, Xi and Putin: Uniting Their Nations, Dividing the World?

Power to the people, not the powerful

The appeal of a strong leader is understandable.

When people feel ignored, insecure or uncertain about the future, a politician promising order, national renewal and decisive action can become enormously powerful. Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin emerged from different societies and political systems, but each has placed national strength at the centre of a compelling political story.

Trump promised to put America first and challenge an establishment that many voters believed had abandoned them. Xi associated his leadership with China’s national rejuvenation and growing international influence. Putin presented himself as the leader who restored Russian pride and authority after the instability that followed the Soviet Union’s collapse.

All three have united substantial parts of their countries behind a vision of national strength.

The danger is that, while strengthening national unity, their competing ambitions risk tearing the wider world apart.

The strongman paradox

Trump, Xi and Putin should not be treated as identical.

Trump operates within an American constitutional democracy containing competitive elections, independent courts and established checks on executive power. Xi leads a one-party state, while Putin presides over a highly centralised Russian political system.

Nevertheless, their leadership styles reveal a common political temptation: concentrating public identity, national purpose and political authority around one dominant figure.

This can be effective. It offers people a clear story about who they are, what has gone wrong and who is to blame. It promises that national decline can be reversed if the country unites behind the leader.

But this form of unity often requires an opponent.

Domestic critics become enemies. Independent journalism becomes disloyal. International relationships are reduced to contests between winners and losers. Compromise is portrayed as weakness, while confrontation becomes evidence of strength.

Nationalism can unite a country, but it can also divide humanity.

A leader who mobilises support through confrontation at home may be tempted to use the same approach abroad. The world then becomes a collection of increasingly assertive states, each pursuing national advantage while shared dangers continue to grow.

Putin and the politics of control

Putin’s supporters credit him with restoring stability and returning Russia to the centre of international affairs. Yet this restoration has been accompanied by a severe concentration of political power.

Freedom House classifies Russia as “Not Free” and describes a political system in which power is concentrated around Putin, genuine opposition is suppressed, elections are manipulated and independent media face extensive restrictions.

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine demonstrates the international consequences of this concentration of authority. On 2 March 2022, the United Nations General Assembly voted by 141 votes to five to demand that Russia end its use of force and withdraw its troops from Ukraine.

Whatever unity Putin has created around Russian identity and power, it has come alongside war, isolation and a confrontation that has destabilised Europe and caused immense human suffering.

That is not strength in the service of humanity. It is power exercised without sufficient accountability for its consequences.

Xi and China’s national rejuvenation

China’s economic transformation is one of the defining developments of modern history. The country has become an economic, technological and geopolitical power capable of shaping the international system.

Xi has placed this rise within a wider narrative of national rejuvenation, discipline and collective purpose.

Yet economic progress does not remove the need for liberty and accountability. Freedom House classifies China as “Not Free” and reports extensive Communist Party control over political expression, the media, online speech and civil society. It also describes Xi as having consolidated personal power to a degree not seen in China for decades.

China has every right to pursue prosperity and an influential place in the world. Its people deserve the benefits of economic development.

But prosperity should not require citizens to surrender their right to question authority. Stability should not depend upon silencing disagreement. National confidence should not become a justification for permanent political control.

Trump and the pressures on democracy

Trump’s rise cannot be explained simply by dismissing his supporters.

Millions of Americans believed that established political institutions had stopped representing them. Trump turned their frustration into a movement built around national restoration, opposition to political elites and the promise of American strength.

That support is real and must be understood.

But democratic leadership requires more than winning elections. It requires respect for constitutional limits, independent institutions, lawful opposition and the principle that political rivals are competitors rather than enemies.

The danger arises when loyalty to a leader becomes more important than loyalty to democratic principles. Attacks on independent journalism, distrust of elections and hostile rhetoric towards opponents can weaken the culture on which democracy depends.

The V-Dem Institute’s Democracy Report 2025 describes a continuing global trend of autocratisation and declining freedom of expression. Its warning is wider than any one politician or country: democratic institutions can deteriorate when societies stop defending them.

Trump may claim to unite Americans around national renewal. Yet a movement that sharpens internal division and treats international cooperation primarily as a test of dominance risks weakening both democracy at home and trust abroad.

A planet that requires cooperation

The central failure of strongman politics is that it offers national answers to planetary problems.

Climate change does not recognise borders.

Pollution does not stop at customs checkpoints.

Pandemics do not require passports.

Artificial intelligence, cyber security, nuclear security and economic instability cannot be managed by one country acting alone.

The atmosphere is shared. The oceans are shared. The consequences of war, environmental destruction and technological disruption are shared.

Humanity therefore needs leaders capable of looking beyond personal authority and short-term national advantage. A politician may strengthen one country temporarily, but no nation can remain secure in a world increasingly defined by conflict, mistrust and environmental decline.

The true test of leadership is no longer simply whether a politician can unite a nation. It is whether that politician can help nations cooperate without sacrificing freedom, dignity or democratic accountability.

Power to the people

Democracy is imperfect because people are imperfect. Its debates can be slow, its compromises frustrating and its institutions vulnerable to complacency.

Yet democracy contains an essential wisdom: no individual should be trusted with unlimited power.

The answer to failing institutions is not blind faith in a strong leader. It is stronger accountability, greater participation, independent journalism, effective courts and citizens prepared to question authority.

Trump, Xi and Putin may each claim success in uniting people around national strength. History will ask a more important question: did their leadership help humanity confront its common challenges, or did it leave the world more divided, suspicious and dangerous?

A leader who unites a country achieves something significant.

A leader who helps unite humanity around peace, freedom and the protection of our shared planet achieves something far greater.

Our future cannot be organised around the ambitions of a few powerful individuals. It must be shaped by informed citizens, accountable institutions and governments that recognise their first duty is to the people.

They may have succeeded in uniting their nations behind them.

The danger is that they risk tearing the world apart.

Power to the people, not the powerful.

Footnotes

1. Freedom House, Russia: Freedom in the World 2025.

2. United Nations General Assembly, Resolution ES-11/1: Aggression Against Ukraine, adopted 2 March 2022.

3. United Nations, General Assembly Overwhelmingly Adopts Resolution Demanding the Russian Federation End Its Use of Force in Ukraine and Withdraw All Troops, 2 March 2022.

4. Freedom House, China: Freedom in the World 2025.

5. V-Dem Institute, Democracy Report 2025: 25 Years of Autocratisation – Democracy Trumped?.

Authoritarian Creep: A Global Phenomenon

Why Russia Uses Invasions and Espionage, China Uses Economic Power and State Control, and Iran Uses Proxies and Ideology

By Huw Edwards

Throughout history, societies have faced a recurring political question: how should power be organised, exercised and restrained?

The answer offered by liberal democracy differs profoundly from the answer offered by authoritarianism.

Liberal democracies are built upon the belief that individual citizens possess rights that exist independently of the state. Governments derive legitimacy from the consent of the governed, political leaders can be peacefully removed, and power is constrained through institutions, laws and democratic accountability.

Authoritarian systems begin from a different premise. They tend to prioritise stability, control, national unity and regime preservation above individual liberty, political pluralism and open competition for power.

Today, three of the most influential authoritarian states in the world, Russia, China and Iran, demonstrate how different forms of authoritarianism can pursue remarkably similar goals through very different methods.

Russia often relies upon military force, covert operations and strategic disruption.

China frequently employs economic leverage, technological capability and extensive state control.

Iran projects influence through ideology, regional alliances and proxy organisations.

Understanding these differences, and the similarities beneath them, is essential if democracies are to understand the challenges of the twenty-first century.


The Authoritarian Mindset

Authoritarian systems place a high value on stability, control and political continuity.

Unlike liberal democracies, where governments change through open competition and criticism is accepted as a normal feature of political life, authoritarian systems frequently view dissent as a potential threat to state security. Freedom House consistently characterises Russia, China and Iran as political systems with significant restrictions on political rights and civil liberties.

This creates a distinctive political psychology.

Opposition becomes suspicious.

Independent media become problematic.

Civil society organisations become competing centres of influence.

External criticism becomes evidence of hostile intent.

Power becomes increasingly concentrated because those in authority begin to view challenges not as legitimate democratic participation but as threats requiring management, containment or suppression.


Liberty, Democracy and Human Flourishing

At their best, liberal democracies are founded upon a radically different idea.

They begin with the belief that every individual possesses inherent dignity and the capacity to think, choose and determine the direction of their own lives.

Political authority is not granted because rulers claim superior wisdom, religious authority or ideological correctness.

Instead, legitimacy flows upwards from citizens.

Freedom of thought allows individuals to question inherited assumptions and official narratives.

Freedom of conscience protects religious, philosophical and moral beliefs.

Freedom of expression enables criticism of governments and powerful institutions.

Freedom of association allows citizens to organise, innovate and advocate for change.

Democratic self-determination gives citizens a peaceful means of shaping the future of their societies.

These freedoms can make democracies appear messy.

Debates are often loud.

Elections create uncertainty.

Governments are criticised constantly.

Policies are challenged relentlessly.

Yet these apparent weaknesses are also among democracy’s greatest strengths.

Open societies possess mechanisms of self-correction. Bad ideas can be challenged. Corruption can be exposed. Failed leaders can be replaced without revolution or violence. Institutions can adapt because criticism is permitted rather than suppressed.

The philosopher Karl Popper argued that open societies derive strength from the ability to question authority and test ideas through reasoned debate. Closed societies, by contrast, often seek certainty through conformity and obedience.

However, liberty is not simply the freedom to do whatever one wishes.

A successful democratic society depends upon balancing rights with responsibilities.

Liberty cannot flourish if it destroys the liberty of others.

My freedom of speech should not silence yours.

My freedom of belief should not deny your freedom of conscience.

My freedom to pursue prosperity should not remove your opportunity to do likewise.

This principle has deep roots in liberal democratic thought. John Stuart Mill argued that liberty should be protected except where actions cause harm to others. The principle remains one of the foundations of modern democratic societies.

The most successful democracies recognise that freedom is not merely an individual possession.

It is a shared public good.

Rights and responsibilities exist together.

Rights without responsibility risk becoming selfishness.

Responsibility without rights becomes oppression.

This balance creates a democratic ecosystem where citizens enjoy freedom while respecting the equal freedoms of others.

Such systems are rarely perfect.

But they have repeatedly demonstrated a greater capacity for innovation, adaptation, accountability and peaceful social progress than systems built upon concentrated power and restricted dissent.


Russia: Power Through Fear, Force and Disruption

Modern Russia derives much of its strategic worldview from history.

Repeated invasions, imperial collapse and geopolitical insecurity have contributed to a political culture in which strength, security and national resilience are frequently prioritised above political liberalisation.

According to Freedom House, power in modern Russia is highly concentrated around the presidency, with restrictions on opposition activity, independent media and political dissent.

Externally, Russia has increasingly relied upon a combination of military intervention, intelligence operations, cyber activities, espionage, disinformation campaigns and covert influence operations.

NATO and the UK House of Commons Library describe Russia as a significant practitioner of hybrid warfare, combining military power with propaganda, cyber operations, political interference and strategic disruption.

Russia’s objectives appear to include:

  • Preserving regime security.
  • Maintaining regional influence.
  • Preventing perceived strategic encirclement.
  • Reasserting great-power status.
  • Challenging aspects of Western geopolitical influence.

Russia’s approach seeks influence through strategic leverage, coercion and disruption.

In effect, it often uses fear and instability as instruments of statecraft.


China: Power Through Wealth, Technology and Control

China presents a different model of authoritarianism.

While Russia frequently projects military power, China’s influence increasingly flows through economics, technology, trade, investment and state-directed development.

The Chinese Communist Party has overseen one of the most significant economic transformations in modern history, lifting hundreds of millions of people out of poverty while simultaneously maintaining strict political control.

Rather than political liberalisation accompanying economic development, China has developed sophisticated systems of surveillance, censorship and state oversight.

Analysts at Chatham House describe aspects of this model as “smart authoritarianism”, combining technological innovation with centralised political control.

China’s goals appear to include:

  • Preserving Communist Party rule.
  • Maintaining social and political stability.
  • Expanding technological leadership.
  • Increasing geopolitical influence.
  • Reducing reliance on foreign technologies and strategic vulnerabilities.

Researchers at CSIS have argued that China increasingly uses economic statecraft and economic pressure as instruments of foreign policy, leveraging trade relationships and market access to shape the behaviour of other states.

Unlike Russia, China’s preferred weapon is often not military force but economic centrality.

Its influence grows when other nations become dependent upon its markets, products, capital and supply chains.

The objective is often not conquest but indispensability.


Iran: Power Through Ideology and Proxies

Iran represents a third authoritarian model.

Unable to match the economic strength of China or the military reach of Russia, the Islamic Republic developed alternative methods of projecting power.

Since the 1979 Revolution, Iran has invested heavily in regional alliances, ideological networks and proxy organisations.

According to the Council on Foreign Relations, Iran has constructed an extensive network of allied groups across the Middle East to advance its regional interests and strategic objectives.

The Wilson Center similarly documents Iranian support for organisations operating across multiple countries through training, funding and logistical assistance.

Iran’s objectives appear to include:

  • Preserving the Islamic Republic.
  • Expanding regional influence.
  • Countering rival powers.
  • Supporting aligned movements.
  • Promoting what Iranian leaders describe as the “Axis of Resistance.”

Rather than projecting power through large-scale invasions, Iran frequently projects influence through intermediaries, allowing Tehran to shape regional events whilst reducing the costs and risks associated with direct military confrontation.


Different Methods, Similar Goals

Russia sends soldiers.

China sends salesmen.

Iran sends proxies.

Yet despite these differences, all three systems display several recurring authoritarian themes.

Regime Survival

The preservation of the existing political order is often treated as the highest priority.

Challenges to governing authority become security concerns rather than democratic disagreements.

Concentration of Power

Authority becomes concentrated within political elites, ruling parties, security institutions or leadership structures.

Checks and balances are weakened.

Independent scrutiny becomes limited.

Information Control

Control of information becomes strategically important.

Media, communication and public narratives are managed to varying degrees in support of political stability.

National Influence

Each seeks to shape events beyond its borders and expand its influence within its surrounding region and the wider international system.

Resistance to External Pressure

All three challenge aspects of a liberal democratic, Western-led international order that they perceive as inconsistent with their interests or threatening to regime security.


Authoritarian Creep Beyond Authoritarian States

It would be a mistake to believe these dynamics exist only in Russia, China or Iran.

Authoritarian creep can occur within democratic societies as well.

The process rarely begins with tanks in the streets or the abolition of elections.

It more often begins with rhetoric.

Political opponents become enemies.

Journalists become traitors.

Courts become obstacles.

Facts become negotiable.

Criticism becomes disloyalty.

Gradually, the culture of democracy begins to weaken.

The greatest danger is not that democracies become authoritarian overnight.

The greater danger is that citizens become comfortable with the slow erosion of democratic norms so long as it appears to deliver security, certainty or partisan advantage.

History repeatedly demonstrates that freedom is rarely lost all at once.

It is weakened incrementally.


Final Thoughts

Russia, China and Iran represent different expressions of authoritarian power.

Russia frequently relies upon military force, espionage and strategic disruption.

China relies heavily upon economic influence, technological capability and state control.

Iran relies upon ideology, proxy networks and regional alliances.

Their methods differ.

Their histories differ.

Their ideologies differ.

Yet they share a common conviction that stability, control and concentrated authority are preferable to the uncertainties of liberal democracy.

Liberal democracies offer a different vision.

They place their trust not in rulers but in citizens.

Not in uniformity but in pluralism.

Not in obedience but in participation.

Not in state-directed truth but in open inquiry and debate.

The strength of democracy is not that it eliminates disagreement.

The strength of democracy is that it allows disagreement to exist without violence.

It allows societies to change leaders without revolution.

It allows citizens to challenge authority without fear.

It allows individuals to think, believe, speak and organise freely while recognising that those same freedoms belong equally to others.

That balance between liberty and responsibility remains one of humanity’s greatest political achievements.

The challenge of the twenty-first century is not merely understanding the ambitions of authoritarian states abroad.

It is ensuring that democratic societies remain confident in the values that have historically given free people the power to shape their own futures.


References and Further Reading

United Nations, Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948).

Freedom House – Russia Country Profile.

Freedom House – Global Freedom Reports.

NATO – Countering Hybrid Threats.

NATO – Information Threats and Disinformation.

UK House of Commons Library – Russia’s Hybrid Warfare Campaign in Europe.

Chatham House – China’s Smart Authoritarianism.

CSIS – China’s Economic Statecraft and Economic Coercion.

Council on Foreign Relations – Iran’s Regional Armed Network.

Wilson Center – Iran’s Islamist Proxies in the Middle East.

Karl Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945).

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (1859).

The Psychology of Extremism: Fear, Belonging and Authoritarianism

By Huw Edwards

Political extremism is often discussed in terms of elections, parties and policies. Less attention is paid to the psychological forces that can draw people towards movements built on division, fear and hostility. Yet a substantial body of research suggests that emotions, identity and perceived threats can be powerful influences on political behaviour.

Understanding these dynamics is not an attempt to excuse extremism. Rather, it is an effort to understand how fear, resentment and authoritarian thinking can become politically influential, particularly during periods of uncertainty and social change.

Fear as a Political Drug

Fear is one of humanity’s oldest survival mechanisms. It evolved to protect us from danger, prompting rapid responses to genuine threats. However, psychologists have long observed that fear can also influence political attitudes and behaviour.

Research highlighted by the American Psychological Association has shown that fear can be a powerful political motivator, increasing support for strong leaders, security measures and more restrictive policies when people perceive threats to their safety, identity or way of life.

Far-right movements frequently centre political messaging around danger and decline. Immigrants, minorities, political opponents, international organisations and cultural change are often presented not simply as challenges but as existential threats.

When people are repeatedly exposed to narratives of crisis and threat, they may begin to interpret events through a lens of permanent insecurity. Complex social problems become simplified into emotionally compelling stories involving victims, heroes and enemies.

Fear offers something many people crave during uncertain times: certainty.

The Human Need to Belong

Psychological research suggests that human beings possess a deep need for social identity and belonging.

Social Identity Theory, developed by Henri Tajfel and John Turner, demonstrated that people naturally divide the world into groups, forming emotional attachments to their own communities while distinguishing themselves from outsiders.

This tendency is not inherently harmful. It is part of normal human psychology.

The danger emerges when political movements define belonging through exclusion. Loyalty to one’s group becomes dependent upon hostility towards another group. Political identity becomes less about what people support and more about whom they oppose.

Many extremist movements are remarkably successful not because they persuade people to hate immediately, but because they first provide meaning, purpose and community. The hatred often arrives later, justified as loyalty or defence of the group.

The Appeal of Simple Answers

Modern societies are extraordinarily complex.

Economic inequality, housing pressures, globalisation, technological disruption and cultural change all generate genuine anxieties. Democratic politics frequently struggles to provide quick solutions.

Extremist ideologies exploit this complexity by offering simple explanations.

If there is a social problem, identify a scapegoat.

If there is uncertainty, seek a strong leader.

If institutions appear ineffective, portray democratic checks and balances as obstacles.

Such narratives are psychologically appealing because they reduce ambiguity. They transform complicated issues into emotionally satisfying stories with clear villains and easy solutions.

Reality, however, is rarely so simple.

Authoritarianism and the Desire for Order

One of the most influential areas of research into extremism concerns authoritarian attitudes.

Political psychologist Robert Altemeyer developed the concept of Right-Wing Authoritarianism (RWA), describing a cluster of attitudes characterised by strong deference to authority, aggression towards approved targets and a preference for social conformity.

Research into authoritarianism suggests that some individuals become particularly attracted to rigid hierarchies and strong leadership during periods of uncertainty or perceived social threat.

This does not mean everyone holding conservative views is authoritarian. Nor does it imply all right-wing movements are extremist.

However, history demonstrates that movements emphasising unquestioning obedience, strongman leadership and hostility towards dissent can become fertile ground for anti-democratic thinking.

When citizens are encouraged to place loyalty to leaders above loyalty to democratic principles, institutions such as courts, independent media and civil society organisations can begin to be seen as enemies rather than safeguards.

How Violence Becomes Acceptable

Most people do not begin their political journey by embracing violence.

Acceptance of violence usually develops gradually through a process of moral disengagement and dehumanisation.

Researchers studying radicalisation have found recurring patterns across a wide range of extremist ideologies. Opponents are first portrayed as dangerous. They are then framed as threats to society. Eventually they are depicted as fundamentally undeserving of empathy, rights or protection.

At that stage, actions previously regarded as unacceptable may be reinterpreted as necessary acts of defence.

This process has appeared repeatedly throughout history, from fascist movements in Europe to ethnonationalist conflicts and contemporary extremist networks.

Violence rarely begins with violence. It often begins with language that strips away the humanity of others.

The Internet and the Amplification of Extremism

Modern technology has accelerated these psychological processes.

Researchers examining polarisation and radicalisation have found that online environments can intensify feelings of grievance, anger and group identity. Social media platforms often reward emotionally charged content because outrage generates engagement.

As a result, conspiracy theories, fear-based narratives and inflammatory content frequently travel further than nuanced discussion.

Individuals who repeatedly consume such material can become immersed in information ecosystems where extreme beliefs seem mainstream and hostility towards opponents appears normal.

The process is not unique to the far right, but contemporary far-right movements have often proven particularly effective at exploiting these dynamics through narratives focused on loss, decline and threat.

Why Democracy Requires Courage

The opposite of extremism is not weakness.

It is democratic courage.

Democracy requires people to tolerate uncertainty, coexist with disagreement and recognise the humanity of those with whom they profoundly disagree.

Fear offers certainty.

Hatred offers a target.

Authoritarianism offers simple answers.

Democracy offers responsibility.

The challenge facing modern societies is therefore not simply defeating extremist political movements. It is creating social conditions that reduce alienation, strengthen communities and provide citizens with a sense of belonging that does not depend upon fear or hostility towards others.

Final Thoughts

The psychology of extremism reminds us that the temptations of tribalism, fear and resentment are not confined to any single political tradition. They are recurring features of human history.

Research into authoritarianism, social identity and radicalisation suggests that under the right conditions many societies can become vulnerable to political movements that promise certainty, strength and simple answers.

The lesson is not that some people are uniquely flawed while others are immune. Rather, it is that democratic values require constant maintenance.

When fear becomes an identity, hatred can become habitual.

When hatred becomes normalised, violence becomes easier to justify.

The defence of democracy therefore begins not merely in parliaments and courts, but in everyday acts of empathy, critical thinking and respect for the dignity of others.

Sources

  • American Psychological Association Dictionary: Right-Wing Authoritarianism

https://dictionary.apa.org/right-wing-authoritarianism

  • American Psychological Association: Fear as a Political Motivator

https://www.apa.org/news/apa/2020/fear-motivator-elections

  • Encyclopaedia Britannica: Social Identity Theory

https://www.britannica.com/topic/social-identity-theory

  • Tajfel, H. & Turner, J. C. – Social Identity Theory
  • Smith & Thomas (2025) – A Primer on Politicization, Polarization, Radicalization and Activation

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12076042

  • Brookings Institution: Hate Speech and Political Violence

Wales, We Finally Did It

Well done Wales. Onwards and upwards.

I never thought I would write these words.

Wales have beaten New Zealand.

For many rugby nations, beating the All Blacks is a great victory. For Wales, it is something more. It is history. It is emotion. It is generations of hope, disappointment and belief finally rewarded.

Today I found myself thinking not only about the players on the pitch but about everyone who never got to see this day.

The last Welsh victory over New Zealand came in 1953. Think about that for a moment. Since then, generations have been born, grown up, raised families and grown old without ever seeing Wales overcome the All Blacks. Grandparents told stories about it. Parents spoke about it as a distant memory. Children grew up wondering whether they would ever witness it themselves.

And now, finally, we have.

For decades Welsh supporters have turned up with hope in their hearts. We have sung our anthem with pride, watched moments of brilliance, suffered narrow defeats and endured painful losses. Every time we faced New Zealand there was that small voice saying, “Perhaps this time.”

Most of the time, it wasn’t.

But Welsh people are stubborn when it comes to hope.

We keep turning up.

We keep believing.

We keep singing.

That is what makes this victory so special.

It was not won by statistics. It was not won by history. It was won by a group of players who refused to be intimidated by the weight of the past. They wore the red jersey not as a burden but as a privilege.

They played for themselves.

They played for their teammates.

They played for Wales.

Most importantly, they played without fear.

Watching the final moments tick away, I suspect every Welsh supporter felt the same thing. Disbelief. Excitement. Nerves. Then finally, relief.

When the final whistle blew, seventy-three years seemed to disappear in an instant.

Thousands celebrated in Cardiff.

Millions of hearts lifted across Wales.

For one afternoon, all the worries, frustrations and divisions that fill daily life were pushed aside. We were simply Welsh, and we were celebrating together.

That is the magic of sport.

It reminds us who we are.

Wales is a small nation. We do not have the population of the world’s giants. We do not always have the resources. We do not always win.

But what we have is pride.

What we have is passion.

What we have is a spirit that refuses to give up.

This victory belongs to every supporter who stayed loyal through the difficult years. It belongs to every child kicking a rugby ball in a school field. It belongs to every parent who passed on a love of the game. It belongs to every choir voice that has ever joined in the anthem before kick-off.

It belongs to Wales.

The truth is that this result means more because it took so long.

The years of disappointment make the joy sweeter.

The losses make the victory more meaningful.

The waiting makes the moment unforgettable.

Nobody knows what happens next. Rugby has a way of bringing us back down to earth very quickly. There will be more challenges ahead and there will be more difficult days.

But today is not about what comes next.

Today is about celebrating something extraordinary.

A generation has witnessed what previous generations could only dream about.

Wales have beaten New Zealand.

At last.

So raise a glass tonight, sing a song, wear your red jersey with pride and enjoy every moment of it.

Because these are the days that become stories.

These are the days that grandchildren hear about in years to come.

These are the days that remind us why we never stopped believing.

Well done Wales.

The dragon still breathes fire.

And after all these years, it has roared louder than ever.

Onwards and upwards.

Greta Thunberg: A Heroine of Our Lifetime?

Love her or loathe her, few individuals have shaped the global conversation on climate change as profoundly as Greta Thunberg.

From a School Strike to a Global Movement

In August 2018, a fifteen-year-old Swedish student sat outside the Swedish Parliament with a simple sign: Skolstrejk för klimatet (School Strike for Climate). What began as the solitary act of one young person soon became an international movement that inspired millions of young people across continents to demand action on climate change.

Greta Thunberg did not possess political power, wealth or celebrity status. Her influence emerged from something more unusual: moral clarity. At a time when climate science was often discussed in technical reports and diplomatic conferences, she translated a complex issue into a simple question:

If scientists are warning of serious risks, why are governments not acting with greater urgency?

That message resonated with many people who felt frustrated by the gap between political promises and real-world action.

Why Many See Her as a Heroine

Throughout history, societies have often celebrated individuals who challenge established institutions in pursuit of a cause they believe is larger than themselves. Supporters argue that Greta follows this tradition.

First, she demonstrated remarkable courage. Speaking before world leaders, business executives and international organisations requires confidence from anyone, let alone a teenager. Her speeches challenged powerful interests and frequently invited criticism.

Second, she gave voice to a generation. Young people who feel they will live with the consequences of today’s environmental decisions found in Greta a spokesperson willing to articulate their concerns directly and uncompromisingly.

Third, she focused global attention on climate science. Rather than presenting herself as an expert, she repeatedly encouraged people to listen to scientific evidence. Whether one agrees with her methods or not, her activism helped keep climate change in public debate and media coverage.

The Power of Authenticity

One of Greta’s greatest strengths has been authenticity.

In an era where political communication is often heavily managed and polished, she speaks with directness that many people find refreshing. Her willingness to refuse conventional political language has made her a powerful communicator.

There is also a broader lesson here. Historically, meaningful social change often begins when ordinary individuals refuse to accept that difficult problems are someone else’s responsibility. Greta’s campaign demonstrated that age is not necessarily a barrier to influence.

The Criticisms and Controversies

A balanced assessment must acknowledge that Greta remains a controversial figure.

Critics argue that some of her rhetoric can oversimplify complex economic and political challenges. Others believe climate policy requires a more nuanced discussion that balances environmental goals with economic realities, energy security and social impacts.

She has also become a lightning rod for wider cultural and political disagreements. In some cases, public reactions to Greta reveal as much about society’s divisions as they do about Greta herself.

Yet controversy alone does not diminish influence. Many historical reformers, campaigners and activists faced fierce opposition during their lifetimes before later being recognised for their contributions.

Beyond Climate Change

Perhaps Greta’s most important legacy extends beyond environmental policy.

Her story demonstrates that one person can change a global conversation. She challenged assumptions about who gets to participate in public life and who has the authority to question political leaders.

Whether discussing climate change, social justice, democracy or human rights, future generations may take inspiration from her example: that determined individuals can still make themselves heard in an increasingly noisy world.

Final Thoughts: Why I Believe Greta Thunberg Matters

As the author of this article, I freely admit that I am a huge admirer of Greta Thunberg.

What impresses me most is not simply her activism, but her consistency. While many adults make excuses about why change is difficult, delayed or supposedly impossible, Greta has remained focused on what science tells us and on the responsibility each generation has to those that follow.

Too often, politicians speak the language of environmentalism while pursuing policies that fall short of their rhetoric. Greenwashing has become a feature of modern politics, where impressive announcements and ambitious targets can sometimes mask a lack of meaningful action. In some cases, political and corporate decisions continue to contribute to environmental damage while claiming to support sustainability.

Greta Thunberg’s message cuts through that contradiction. Whether one agrees with every argument she makes or not, her position has been remarkably consistent. She asks a straightforward question: if we know there is a problem, why are we not acting with the urgency that the evidence demands?

That clarity of vision is rare. Greta has shown a determination and moral conviction that many public figures struggle to maintain when faced with criticism or political pressure.

History will ultimately decide how she is remembered. Yet from my perspective, Greta Thunberg represents something important: the courage to speak uncomfortable truths, the willingness to challenge powerful institutions and the determination to remain ethically consistent when compromise would be easier.

For those reasons, I believe Greta Thunberg is not only one of the most influential activists of her generation, but a genuine heroine of our lifetime.

The real question is not whether Greta was right to demand action. The question is whether the rest of us will prove worthy of the challenge she has set before us.

Schindler’s List and Gaza: Similarities, Differences and the Importance of Historical Perspective

How should we compare human suffering across different periods of history, and where should we draw the line?

Images emerging from Gaza since October 2023 have prompted many people to look to history for comparison. Among the most controversial parallels drawn by some commentators is between the experiences of Palestinians in Gaza and the Jewish victims portrayed in Steven Spielberg’s acclaimed film Schindler’s List.

Such comparisons are emotionally charged and fiercely debated. For some, they highlight universal lessons about displacement, civilian suffering and the dangers of dehumanisation. For others, they risk misunderstanding or diminishing the unique horror of the Holocaust.

The challenge is to examine these arguments honestly while respecting both historical truth and contemporary human suffering.

Why Some People Draw Parallels

Those who draw parallels are usually not claiming that Gaza and the Holocaust are identical events. Instead, they point to experiences that appear similar from a humanitarian perspective.

Forced Displacement

One of the most moving aspects of Schindler’s List is the depiction of Jewish families being driven from their homes, often with little more than they could carry.

Similarly, many Palestinians in Gaza have experienced repeated displacement during the conflict, moving between shelters, encampments and temporary refuges. According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), large numbers of Gaza’s residents have been displaced multiple times during the war.

Source: UN OCHA – Occupied Palestinian Territory

Civilian Vulnerability

Spielberg’s film portrays ordinary civilians trapped within forces beyond their control. Children, elderly people and families become victims of political and military decisions made by others.

Human rights organisations including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have raised concerns regarding the protection of civilians in Gaza, documenting civilian casualties and the destruction of civilian infrastructure.

Sources:

Restrictions on Movement

The Kraków Ghetto depicted in Schindler’s List existed under severe restrictions on movement and access to resources.

Critics of Israeli policy have pointed to Gaza’s long-standing border restrictions and blockade as creating conditions in which daily life is heavily constrained. Humanitarian agencies have repeatedly expressed concern regarding access to food, medicine and humanitarian supplies.

Source: United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA)

Dehumanisation

Many scholars argue that mass atrocities become possible only when populations are viewed as less than fully human.

Some commentators argue that language used by extremists on all sides of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict demonstrates how easily people can be reduced to labels rather than recognised as individuals deserving dignity and protection.

This is perhaps the most powerful lesson many people take from Schindler’s List: that the loss of empathy often precedes the loss of human rights.

Why Many Historians Reject Direct Comparisons

Despite recognising civilian suffering in Gaza, many Holocaust scholars strongly caution against drawing direct equivalence between the Holocaust and the current conflict.

The Holocaust Was a Programme of Extermination

The Holocaust was a state-led project by Nazi Germany aimed at the systematic elimination of Jewish people across Europe.

The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum describes it as the persecution and murder of six million Jews by the Nazi regime and its collaborators.

Source: United States Holocaust Memorial Museum – Introduction to the Holocaust

The Holocaust involved death camps, gas chambers, forced labour systems and an explicit racial ideology dedicated to the destruction of an entire people.

Different Historical Contexts

Jewish victims in Nazi-occupied Europe were targeted because they were Jews.

The Gaza conflict exists within a very different context involving territorial disputes, competing national movements, military operations and the role of Hamas, which carried out the attacks on Israel on 7 October 2023 and continues to be engaged in armed conflict with Israel.

Many historians argue that these distinctions are essential and should not be overlooked.

Distinct Methods and Objectives

The Holocaust’s machinery of extermination was designed specifically for mass murder.

The suffering seen in Gaza arises from warfare, bombardment, siege conditions, displacement and the collapse of civilian infrastructure.

While the humanitarian consequences may be devastating, historians argue that the objectives, methods and historical circumstances differ significantly.

Why the Comparison Remains Controversial

For many Jewish people, comparisons between Israel and Nazi Germany can feel deeply painful because they appear to place the descendants of Holocaust survivors in the role of Holocaust perpetrators.

The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) notes that some comparisons between contemporary Israeli policy and Nazi policy may constitute antisemitism depending on context and intent.

Source: IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism

Conversely, many Palestinian advocates argue that historical comparisons serve as warnings rather than accusations. They contend that the promise of “Never Again” should apply universally to all peoples facing severe humanitarian crises.

International Law and Current Debates

Legal arguments regarding Gaza continue to be examined internationally.

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is currently hearing proceedings relating to allegations under the Genocide Convention. The Court has issued provisional measures but has not reached a final judgment on whether genocide has occurred.

Source: International Court of Justice – South Africa v Israel

As a result, journalists, historians and commentators should exercise caution when making definitive legal claims.

A HuwSpace Perspective

History does not serve us well when it becomes a weapon. It serves us best when it becomes a teacher.

The Holocaust remains one of the most meticulously documented and uniquely horrific atrocities in human history. Its ideological commitment to the elimination of a people places it in a category of its own.

Yet acknowledging that uniqueness should never require indifference to the suffering of civilians elsewhere.

There are reasonable arguments that some humanitarian experiences shown in Schindler’s List—displacement, fear, family separation, dependence on aid and civilian vulnerability—can help people empathise with those suffering in Gaza today.

There are equally reasonable arguments that direct comparisons between the Holocaust and the Gaza conflict overlook profound historical differences and risk distorting our understanding of both.

Perhaps the most important lesson is not that the two situations are the same.

It is that every civilian life matters.

The strength of Schindler’s List lies not in teaching us which historical events are identical, but in reminding us what can happen when human beings stop seeing one another as human.

That lesson remains as relevant today as it was when the film first appeared in 1993.


Further Reading

Gaza’s Humanitarian Crisis and the Question of Political Blame

By Huw Edwards | HuwSpace.com

Introduction

I find the suffering in Gaza difficult to write about because of its scale and because so much of it appears preventable. Families who never chose war are now living through conditions that many humanitarian organisations describe as catastrophic. Flooded tent camps, food insecurity, damaged hospitals and the collapse of public infrastructure have become part of daily life for millions of civilians.

In early November 2026, severe winter storms struck Gaza, flooding makeshift shelters housing displaced families. Mattresses, blankets and food supplies were destroyed by sewage-contaminated floodwater. For many families there was nowhere else to go. According to United Nations humanitarian agencies, more than a million displaced Palestinians are facing another winter in emergency shelters while reconstruction remains stalled.[1]

The obvious question is why.

Critics argue that primary responsibility lies with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government, whose military decisions and restrictions on aid have contributed directly to the humanitarian conditions now facing Gaza’s civilian population. They further argue that the United States and Britain, by continuing military support and arms exports, bear a degree of moral and political responsibility for the consequences.

The Human Reality Behind the Headlines

The humanitarian emergency in Gaza cannot be understood through statistics alone.

Behind every destroyed building is a family. Behind every damaged hospital is a patient without treatment. Behind every contaminated water supply is a child facing disease.

According to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), thousands of shelters were either destroyed or damaged during recent flooding, while hundreds of thousands of people remain exposed to future weather-related risks.[2]

Medical organisations have warned of increasing respiratory illnesses, waterborne diseases and hypothermia among vulnerable populations.[3]

The crisis is therefore not simply about war. It is about the long-term consequences of damaged infrastructure, displacement and restricted access to resources necessary for survival.

Why Critics Focus on Netanyahu’s Government

Critics of the Israeli government point first to the scale of destruction across Gaza.

Human rights organisations including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have documented extensive damage to residential areas, hospitals, sanitation systems, schools and water infrastructure throughout the conflict.[4][5]

Their argument is straightforward.

A government that possesses overwhelming military power also carries responsibilities towards civilian populations affected by its actions. Critics contend that the destruction of essential infrastructure has created the very conditions that now threaten civilian lives through disease, hunger, flooding and exposure.

The question is not simply whether military action occurred.

The question is whether those actions were conducted in a manner consistent with the protection of civilian populations required under international humanitarian law.

The Aid and Access Question

Equally controversial are restrictions on humanitarian aid and reconstruction materials entering Gaza.

Humanitarian organisations have repeatedly argued that shortages of fuel, water equipment, construction materials, pumps, sanitation supplies and shelter equipment have significantly worsened conditions for civilians.[6]

Critics contend that when a government controls access points into a territory, it assumes responsibility to ensure that civilians are able to obtain food, water, medicines and shelter.

This criticism has become especially prominent following reports that large quantities of aid remain available outside Gaza while distribution and entry continue to face obstacles.[7]

Israeli officials reject many of these criticisms, arguing that restrictions are necessary for security reasons and to prevent resources from reaching Hamas.

Nevertheless, humanitarian organisations continue to argue that the practical result has been severe hardship for civilians.

The Role of the United States and Britain

For many critics the chain of responsibility does not end with Israel.

The United States remains Israel’s principal military partner and supplier. Billions of dollars in military aid, weapons systems and diplomatic support have helped sustain Israel’s military capabilities over many years.[8]

Britain plays a far smaller role but has nevertheless licensed military exports and components used within weapons systems supplied to Israel.[9]

Critics argue that governments supplying weapons cannot completely separate themselves from how those weapons are ultimately used.

Their argument is not necessarily that American or British leaders directly caused civilian suffering. Rather, they contend that continued support helped make military operations possible and therefore carries moral and political consequences.

International Law and Responsibility

International humanitarian law imposes obligations on all parties engaged in armed conflict.

The Fourth Geneva Convention requires protection of civilian populations and the facilitation of humanitarian relief where civilians are in need.[10]

Legal scholars and international organisations have therefore raised questions concerning:

  • Destruction of civilian infrastructure.
  • Protection of hospitals and healthcare facilities.
  • Access to food, water and humanitarian assistance.
  • The proportionality of military actions.
  • Restrictions affecting civilian survival.

In addition, the International Court of Justice has considered questions relating to Israel’s obligations toward Palestinians living in the occupied territories.[11]

While final legal determinations remain subject to judicial processes rather than political debate, critics argue that the available evidence justifies continued investigation and scrutiny.

Arms Exports and Allied Responsibility

The legal debate extends beyond Israel itself.

Britain is a signatory to the United Nations Arms Trade Treaty, which requires exporting states to assess whether military equipment could contribute to serious violations of international humanitarian law.[12]

Campaigners, lawyers and humanitarian organisations have argued that where substantial risks exist, arms transfers should be suspended.

The UK government’s 2024 decision to suspend a number of export licences reflected concerns that some equipment could potentially be used in ways inconsistent with international humanitarian law.[13]

Critics argue that this demonstrates an awareness of risk and strengthens the case for examining broader accountability among arms-supplying states.

Political Responsibility Versus Criminal Responsibility

It is important to distinguish criticism from legal findings.

Political responsibility exists whenever elected leaders make decisions that contribute to foreseeable outcomes.

Criminal responsibility requires evidence tested before courts and judged according to established legal standards.

Reasonable people can disagree about where legal responsibility begins and ends.

However, many observers argue that political responsibility is already clear.

If government decisions contribute to widespread civilian suffering, displacement, destruction of infrastructure and obstacles to humanitarian relief, those decisions deserve scrutiny regardless of whether criminal liability is ultimately established.

The Danger of Dehumanisation

One of the most disturbing aspects of the Gaza crisis is how easily some people dismiss the suffering of civilians.

Social media often encourages tribal thinking. Human beings become statistics. Entire populations become symbols in political arguments.

The result is dehumanisation.

Whether discussing Palestinians in Gaza, Israelis living under threat, or refugees elsewhere in the world, compassion should never depend upon nationality, ethnicity or political allegiance.

No child chooses the circumstances of their birth.

No family deserves to lose access to shelter, healthcare, food or clean water because of decisions made by political leaders.

Conclusion

Critics of Benjamin Netanyahu’s government argue that Gaza’s humanitarian catastrophe is not an unavoidable natural disaster but the consequence of political and military decisions that devastated infrastructure and restricted the conditions necessary for civilian survival.

They further argue that countries such as the United States and Britain share responsibility because military assistance, arms exports and diplomatic support helped sustain policies that contributed to the crisis.

Others disagree, pointing to Hamas’s role in initiating conflict and maintaining military infrastructure within civilian areas.

Yet whatever position one takes on the wider conflict, the reality remains difficult to ignore.

Millions of civilians are living through extraordinary hardship.

History will ultimately judge not only those who carried out policies and military operations but also those who possessed the power to influence events and chose not to act differently.

The central moral question remains unchanged:

When immense suffering is foreseeable, what responsibility falls upon those with the power to prevent it?

References & Endnotes

1 United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), Humanitarian Situation Report: Heavy Rains in the Gaza Strip (8 November 2026). Available at: OCHA Humanitarian Situation Report

2 United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), Gaza Emergency and Flood Impact Updates. Available at: OCHA Occupied Palestinian Territory

3 United Nations News, Flooding and Winter Conditions Threaten Gaza’s Displaced Population. Available at: UN News Coverage

4 Amnesty International, Israel and Occupied Palestinian Territory Research and Reports. Available at: Amnesty International Middle East Research

5 Human Rights Watch, Israel and Palestine Research Collection. Available at: Human Rights Watch Middle East

6 International Rescue Committee, Humanitarian Analysis and Emergency Response Information. Available at: International Rescue Committee

7 ReliefWeb, Occupied Palestinian Territory Humanitarian Updates. Available at: ReliefWeb Gaza Reports

8 United States Congressional Research Service, U.S. Foreign Assistance to Israel. Available at: Congressional Research Service Reports

9 UK Government, Strategic Export Controls Licensing Data. Available at: UK Strategic Export Controls

10 International Committee of the Red Cross, Fourth Geneva Convention Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War (1949). Available at: Fourth Geneva Convention

11 International Court of Justice, Official Judgments, Advisory Opinions and Orders. Available at: International Court of Justice

12 United Nations, Arms Trade Treaty. Available at: United Nations Arms Trade Treaty

13 UK Government, UK Suspends Around 30 Arms Export Licences to Israel for Use in Gaza. Available at: UK Government Statement

14 United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA). Available at: UNRWA

15 World Health Organization, Health Emergency Reports and Situation Updates. Available at: World Health Organization Emergencies

16 United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. Available at: OHCHR